Picture: Peter Klaunzer/EPA/Taken on 26 July 2016 – Swiss pilot Bertrand Piccard, right, initiator and chairperson of the Solar Impulse project; and Andre Borschberg, left, Swiss pilot and co-founder of the Solar Impulse project, celebrate with Sultan Bin Ahmed Al Jaber, Minister of State and CEO of Masdar, in front of the Solar Impulse 2 (Si2) aircraft after landing at Al Bateen Executive Airport in Abu Dhabi, UAE, early 26 July 2016. Al Jaber is more than an oil company leader; as chairperson of rapidly growing global renewable energy company, Masdar, he has spoken openly about the importance of significantly curbing greenhouse gas emissions, the writer says.
By NJ Ayuk
The backlash in recent days about the selection of Sultan Al Jaber, chief executive of the Abu Dhabi National Oil Company (ADNOC), to serve as president of the next United Nations Climate Conference (COP28) has been quite … dramatic.
The decision to have him lead the conference has been described as “a fox watching the henhouse,” asking “arms dealers to lead peace talks”, and “putting the head of a tobacco company in charge of negotiating an anti-smoking treaty”.
Tasneem Essop, the executive director of Climate Action Network International, went further, saying, “He cannot preside over a process that is tasked to address the climate crisis with such a conflict of interest - heading an industry that is responsible for the crisis itself. If he does not step down as CEO, it will be tantamount to a full-scale capture of the UN climate talks by a petrostate national oil company and its associated fossil fuel lobbyists.”
And Tzeporah Berman, chair of the Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty, told ABC News that the selection of Al Jaber to oversee COP28 is a “devastating blow to the climate negotiations at a critical moment in history”.
I could go on, but instead, I’d like to describe why I think those views are wrong-headed and why the African Energy Chamber supports Al Jaber’s selection.
Frankly, I’ve seen rhetoric like this before. Only it was about the “grave dangers posed by fossil fuels”, the “evils of the oil and gas industry”, and how “Africa’s vulnerable populations must be protected from ongoing oil and gas production” and their role in triggering climate-related disasters.
I realise that the protests we’re seeing in Al Jaber’s case are based on the belief that, like oil and water, the petroleum industry and meaningful climate change prevention simply don’t mix.
But that assumption is false. If we’re going to have a just transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy, we’ll need both. We’ll need fossil fuels to ensure energy security and drive industrialization in developing nations, even as the world works to pull together the necessary investments, infrastructure, and governance to make a world fuelled by renewable energy work.
Al Jaber understands that. He’s witnessed the painful results of divesting from fossil fuels prematurely — just look at the energy crisis in Europe — and he’s calling for a more pragmatic approach to protecting the world from climate change. He’s calling for an approach that doesn’t worsen energy poverty and hinder economic growth. As he brilliantly wrote in August, “Our ultimate goal should be to hold back emissions, not progress.”
Yes, Al Jaber is an oil and gas industry leader, and ADNOC has no intention of stopping production in the short term. But, then again, drilling is not the world-threatening activity that environmental organisations make it out to be. And Al Jaber is more than an oil company leader, he’s also the chairperson of the rapidly growing global renewable energy company, Masdar. And he has spoken openly about the importance of significantly curbing greenhouse gas emissions.
In addition to all of that, Al Jaber is a good man and a friend to Africa. I am certain that he is an excellent choice to lead COP28.
The renewable energy company that Al Jaber leads, Masdar, is a model of the important role the petroleum industry can take in moving the world closer to widespread renewable energy usage. The company was formed with the goal of diversifying the United Arab Emirates’ (UAE) economy and energy industry, and its shareholders include ADNOC, Mubadala Investment Company, and Abu Dhabi National Energy Company PJSC (TAQA).
Today, Masdar is active in over 40 countries and invested in projects valued at more than US$20 billion.
A few examples of the company’s impact, just in the past few weeks, include:
ADNOC is demonstrating a solid commitment to protecting the environment, too. Earlier this year, it announced plans to invest UDE15 billion in decarbonisation projects by 2030, including clean power, carbon capture and storage, energy efficiency and reduction of routine gas flaring.
Meanwhile, Al Jaber has made it clear where he stands on emissions and climate change: He recognises the need to get a handle on global emissions.
“We are way off track,” Al Jaber said on January 14 during Abu Dhabi Sustainability Week, hosted by Masdar. “The world is playing catch-up when it comes to the key Paris goal of holding temperatures down to 1.5C, and the hard reality is that to achieve this goal, global emissions must fall 43 percent by 2030.”
But the reason Al Jaber is perfectly suited to serve as COP28 president — and is causing an uproar among environmental organisations — is he doesn’t believe the need to reduce global emissions is cause for irrational decisions. He supports continuing oil and gas production for now, rather than a premature rush to renewables.
His stance is based on a reasoned understanding of the repercussions of giving up fossil fuels too quickly.
“Recent events have shown that unplugging the current energy system before we have built a sufficiently robust alternative puts both economic and climate progress at risk – and calls into question whether we can ensure a just transition that is equitable to all,” Al Jaber wrote in an August op-ed.
“What’s needed is a realistic new strategy that is practical, pro-growth, and pro-climate,” he continued. “The strategy needs to appreciate the complexity of energy and industrial systems, and that the scale of the transition required is colossal, requiring greater alignment and collaboration on everything from capital allocation to product design, public policy, and behavioral change. This means examining the demand side of the energy system first.”
I couldn’t have said it better myself.
But I would add that Africa’s energy industry, and its potential to minimise energy poverty and drive economic growth, have been hindered by non-government organisations (NGOs) exerting immense pressure against investing in our Continent’s oil and gas projects.
The UAE made a sound choice when it selected Al Jaber to lead COP28, and I hope it won’t let the voices of environmental organisations, no matter how loud, bully it into changing course.
NJ Ayuk is Executive Director, African Energy Chamber
This article was first published on the African Energy Chamber website